Rang De Basanti (Rakeysh Omprakash Mehra, 2006)
A few years back, I had a sweet gig where I got free dvd rental from the local arthouse dvd store (now sadly defunct) in return for reviewing whatever the owner picked for me to watch. Seriously: sweetest gig ever – I got to see a huge variety of international festival releases, including some I’d never have picked out for myself, for absolutely zip, as long as I reviewed them for the local college paper.
So that’s how, technically, Rang De Basanti was actually the first Hindi film I ever laid eyes on. I didn’t view it in its entirety – and I don’t think I ever reviewed it, because I remember HATING it. I only got to the intermission before switching it off in favour of some French film, thinking that “Bollywood” was SO not what I had expected. (The next Indian film the dvd store owner would give me to review I absolutely loved: Deepa Mehta’s Water; but it would still be several years till Hindi films lured me back).
Next weird fact: I now own no less than FOUR copies of Rang De Basanti, and I DON’T KNOW HOW OR WHY THIS HAS HAPPENED. Especially since, given that initial experience, my mental association is BAD MOVIE DO NOT WANT.
Guess what? I must have been on crack or something that day (or more likely: the weight of my unrealistic newbie Bollywood expectations: e.g. when video store guy said “this is a Bollywood film” I heard “ALL GLITTER AND SEQUINS AND DANCING AND SINGING AND HAPPINESS ALL THE TIME HOORAY”; + my complete lack of knowledge about India, Indian film and Indian history added up to a disappointing experience) because I put it on the other day, figuring I have four copies, I may as well watch one of them, and OH MY GOD YOU GUYS WHAT IS WRONG WITH ME THAT I WOULD TURN THIS FILM OFF?
I LOVED IT.
I LOVED IT SO MUCH.
I LOVED IT SO MUCH I DON’T EVEN KNOW HOW TO CONVEY TO YOU HOW MUCH I LOVED IT. THERE AREN’T BIG ENOUGH LETTERS OR BIG ENOUGH WORDS.
Rang De Basanti (Paint it Yellow) is the story of Sue (Alice Patten), an aspiring English filmmaker who is inspired by the journals her grandfather kept during the freedom struggle in India in the early 1900s. Her goal is to make a film about Bhaghat Singh and the other revolutionaries who were martyred for the freedom movement in a way that made a deep impression on her grandfather.
Sue flies to Delhi, where she eventually finds a motley crew of fun loving, laid-back college students to play the revolutionaries in her film: DJ (Aamir Khan); Karan (Siddharth); Aslam (Kunal Kapoor); Sukhi (Sharman Joshi) and Sonia (Soha Ali Khan).
The problem, though, is that Sue’s modern-day cast can’t identify with the driven, passionate characters they are supposed to play: well acquainted with partying, but strangers to patriotism, they cannot understand or begin to imagine the mindset of someone who believes in a cause enough to die for it.
Until something happens that changes everything – causing even the most apathetic of the bunch to take drastic action in the name of a cause; causing those with long-held, passionate convictions to reassess everything they thought they knew and defended as “true” and “right”.
The first thing I have to mention about this film is that – contrary to what I had expected – it’s NOT just an Aamir Khan vehicle. It really isn’t. This is a true ensemble effort from a superb cast, and everyone is strong. That said, I have to say that Sharman Joshi as Sukhi especially stood out for me – he’s adorable and underrated; and Atul Kulkarni as Laxman was RIVETING. His scenes alone were amazing enough, but the storyline with Kunal Kapoor GUTTED ME. And yeah, Aamir is slightly too old to be playing a 25 year old, but there are scenes – like this:
- when he breaks down at the breakfast table with Sue – when you forgive him just about anything, because he’s that freaking good.
Secondly: this film is heartbreaking. I don’t think I have EVER cried so much watching ANYTHING. I don’t know if it’s because it juxtaposes historical events against the present day – drawing parallels between the freedom fighting revolutionaries and the Delhi gang, and touching on things like the Jallianwala Bagh Massacre, racial and religious tension, and the story of Bhagat Singh and his contemporaries who died for India’s freedom; or because of the other thematic threads – the kind of Dil Chahta Hai melancholic ideas about growing up and moving on from your idyllic youth; learning unpleasant things about the world and becoming an adult.
Thirdly – having seen my fair share of “patriotic” films (and a large chunk during Deol Dhamaka) I’m more than familiar with the off-putting tendency for these things to descend rapidly into jingoistic, hate-filled ranting; positioning one country or one race on one side as the wonderful ideal and everybody else (if not a specific country, race or religion) as the evil enemy. Rang De Basanti comes at it from an entirely different angle. The very people of the country that is supposed to be celebrated see nothing to celebrate, only seeing its flaws: its corruption, its poverty, its religious tensions. There is no outside “enemy” – the film is about realizing the value of the nation and the message is that no country is perfect, that the people have to work together to make it better.
It’s this kind of patriotism I much prefer to see played out on film – something like this, or Heroes, or Swades.











That sounds like such a cool deal for reviewing films for your dvd shop! Aww I loved this film, it really grasped how these apathetic youth finally grow up and care for their country. This was definitely patriotism done in a fab and understanding way.
ReplyDeleteAnd how cute was Aamir here?! Now if he had only kept his face circa this film to 3 idiots it would have been much better all round!
I cried SO MUCH at this movie!! Seriously sobbed my eyes out - fantastic job from the entire cast. And Atul Kulkarni is amazing - have you seen Khakee yet?
ReplyDeleteAlso, apparently, Alice Patten is impossible to get in touch with. I tried.
@Rum: It was the BEST DEAL EVER! I got to see SO MANY AWESOME films - it was the "alternative/arthouse" dvd store so they carried hard to get foreign films and almost everything that came to the festivals. And the guy who ran it was a HUGE movie buff, as you can imagine, so he would be like "Have you heard of this? NO? YOU HAVE TO WATCH IT!" and would make me watch some crazy, awesome things! Plus he'd ALSO let me choose a film for free too. Man, I miss that place.
ReplyDelete@Filmi Girl: Oh, I have Khakee on my shelf somewhere, I will dig it out! I CRIED SO SO MUCH, I had to put on Jab We Met to recover! And I wondered, as I was watching, whether you'd got in touch with Alice Patten - she was SO GOOD! I loved that the Brits in this weren't the stereotypical "evil bad actors".
Interesting. If i hadnt seen Swades just Dil Chatha hai, i probably would have run a mile. will definitely get this film now, plus they reference it in No one Killed Jessica so it has me intrigued, the march at India Gate with the candles.
ReplyDeleteGreat review, Ness! I will have to watch this one again. I liked it a lot, but yuor enthusiasm suggests I owe it more. I do have to give it another plug for being the only film since Lagaan that I can recall making age-appropriate use of Lata - I love Luka Chuppi!
ReplyDeleteHello there! Didn´t find a better place to poast, forgive me..... Next week is going to be the Magic of Madhuri week! Yes, Madhuri Dixit, one of the greatest actresses of Bollywood ever, will celebrate her 44th birthday, and at that occasion I would like to ask you to publish at least one article related to Madhuri. During the week I shall feature your article/s on my blog and give you a full credit! Please, do join in our celebration of Madhuri Dixit.
ReplyDeleteHow interesting that you had two such different reactions to the same movie! It is such a good film that I am surprised you had a bad reaction that first time, whatever the expectations. We indians do grow up with Bhagat Singh's story which has a deep appeal to all of us. My children, born and brought up in Australia, said when they saw the movie and learnt about Bhagat Singh 'Mum, he is a TERRORIST how can you admire him?' ! :) Terrorist to some, hero to others...thats how it is. I thought the movie was brilliant and the music memorable, especially 'luka chupi' as mentioned by maxqnz.
ReplyDeletehai ness..just came acrss ur blog..loved the fact that u apprciate hindi/bollywood films so much. so will try and read ur blog more..btw i am also a big rang de basanti fan...happy watching dear
ReplyDeleteYou know, I do like the movie, it's those kind of films that make you feel like you can fly or do anything after watching it.
ReplyDeleteBut after putting some thought into it, I discovered I had a HUGE big-ass problem with the ending. So apparently the answer to corruption is violence? I guess the violence is justified in Bhagat Singh's era, but for today's context, no way. The Chief Minister is an asshole, true, but did he deserve to die? I don't think so. And the thing is while watching the film, I was actually rooting for him to be killed and that is disturbing. I think the ending to RDB is just completely contrived and manipulative. I wish the film had gone along the lines of this Rotomac ad, without having to resort to murder.
http://youtu.be/AZ7AXSZAcEA
Anyway my favourite thing about the film was the friendship within the group, it was SO nicely portrayed. I felt like I was a part of that group.
P.s Did anybody else notice that Karan (Siddharth) seems to be quietly in love with Sonia (Soha)? I wonder whether that is intentional or just chemistry. After all, Soha and Sid were dating in real life if I'm not wrong.
@Naf HAH that Rotomac ad is AWESOME! I think what's interesting about RDB is the juxtaposition between the oldschool revolutionaries and the modern day ones, and how they are viewed so differently because of the differing contexts. But yeah, you're right, the friendship aspect is really well done, regardless of how you look at the ending :)
ReplyDelete